≡ Menu

Yet Another Open Letter to Donald Trump

Mr. Donald J. Trump
President, Executive Branch
United States Government
Washington, DC

Mr. Trump:

CNBC reports that you plan either to prohibit American companies from building data centers abroad or to impose a “tremendous tax” on those that do (“Trump vows to stop U.S. companies from building data centers abroad, threatens ‘tremendous tax’,” November 20). You obviously believe that America loses when Americans invest abroad. Yet you also insist that America loses when it runs trade deficits. These two beliefs are inconsistent.

This inconsistency isn’t ideological. It’s accounting. America’s trade deficits are mirrored by surpluses in its capital account. These surpluses arise because foreigners invest more in America than Americans invest abroad. The greater the excess of foreign investment in America over American investment abroad, the larger are America’s trade (or current-account) deficits. And, hence, the more Americans invest abroad, all other things equal, the smaller are U.S. trade deficits. By discouraging Americans from investing abroad, you therefore discourage an activity that reduces America’s trade deficits.

You regularly boast, moreover, about the “trillions” of dollars of foreign investment that you claim your trade policies are drawing into America. Yet each additional dollar of foreign investment in America, other things equal, increases America’s trade deficits. You thus celebrate foreign investment in the U.S. which enlarges U.S. trade deficits while proposing to punish American investment abroad which helps shrink these deficits. You applaud and promote activities that raise U.S. trade deficits while condemning and punishing activities that shrink these deficits.

Unlike you, I don’t regard trade deficits as evidence of economic weakness, or trade surpluses as evidence of economic strength. Both reflect the investment decisions of people around the world. But given your incessant insistence that trade deficits harm America, you can’t sensibly discourage American investment abroad while celebrating foreign investment here. Both policies push the trade deficit in the direction that you deplore.

You can wage war against American investment abroad, or you can wage war against America’s trade deficits. But accounting makes certain that you cannot consistently wage both wars.

Sincerely,
Donald J. Boudreaux
Professor of Economics
and
Martha and Nelson Getchell Chair for the Study of Free Market Capitalism at the Mercatus Center
George Mason University
Fairfax, VA 22030

{ 0 comments }

Some Links

Eric Boehm reports on yet another American business suffering increasing costs because of Trump’s tariffs punitive taxes on Americans’ purchases of imports.

In this letter in the Wall Street Journal, economist Caroline Freund corrects U.S. Trade Representative Jamieson Greer’s tendentious use of some of her research findings:

U.S. Trade Representative Jamieson Greer cites my research correctly but selectively (“The Success of President Trump’s Tariff Policy,” Letters, Nov. 16). Finding that foreign exporters absorbed 40% to 50% of the 2025 tariff increases doesn’t imply U.S. consumers were spared. It means the other 50% to 60% landed on U.S. importers and buyers. That’s not a free lunch; it’s a split bill, with Americans holding the larger tab.

My paper’s point was different: The U.S. extracted a genuine price concession from foreign exporters, consistent with the basic economic logic that a large enough buyer can leverage its market power. That is not an argument for blanket tariffs. The same logic that explains the concession predicts retaliation and long-run costs when trading partners have options.

China and Canada did retaliate, and others may yet follow. More important, the rules-based trading system that took decades to build has been visibly weakened—an erosion that may prove the most consequential and lasting cost of this episode.

What the results don’t imply is that the tariffs were successful on welfare grounds. Any gains from lower import prices must be weighed against the costs of distorted trade, reduced import variety and policy uncertainty.

If the economic ignorance of ‘pro-labor-union’ activists weren’t so harmful to most of the people who actually labor it would be a rich source of comedy – such as (per this report by the Washington Post‘s Editorial Board) these activists’ attempt to unionize Starbucks baristas. A slice:

The union claims to represent about 12,000 baristas at nearly 700 of the company’s more than 16,000 U.S. outposts. Its demands include a $17 wage floor, 4 percent annual raises, minimum staffing of three workers and “just cause” protections against discipline and firing.

Staffing mandates tie managers’ hands when stores are quiet. Automatic raises weaken the link between pay and productivity. “Just cause” rules make it harder to dismiss poor performers. Higher labor costs can mean higher prices for customers, fewer hours for workers, more automation and more store closures.

Competition offers better protection for workers than any union does. As rivals expanded, Starbucks’s share of U.S. coffee-shop spending fell from 52 percent in 2023 to 48 percent in 2025. If baristas don’t like their working conditions, they can take their talents to Dunkin’, Dutch Bros, 7 Brew, Scooter’s, Peet’s, Caribou, Tim Hortons, Blue Bottle or thousands of independent cafes. Restaurants and retailers want those workers, too.

My intrepid Mercatus Center colleague, Veronique de Rugy, continues to wisely warn of the fiscal dangers posed by the Ponzi-scheme-like Social Security program. A slice:

Since the shortfalls began in 2010, Social Security and related interest payments have added $1.6 trillion to the U.S. national debt. With more than 10,000 Americans turning 65 every day, the gap keeps widening. The Cato Institute’s Romina Boccia projects that by 2032, this debt will explode by another $3.4 trillion.

John Puri rightly criticizes Sen. Ron Johnson (R-WI) who – after not inaccurately calling Social Security a Ponzi scheme and then getting into political hot water for this honesty – has just introduced legislation that would only further irresponsibly increase the already gargantuan fiscal burden that Social Security imposes on Americans. A slice:

In short, Johnson’s “solution” is to charge headfirst into the “acute debt crisis” that he warned about hours earlier. If you can’t keep the Ponzi scheme going with current taxpayers — which is what the trust fund’s insolvency concedes — you can fill the $850 trillion gap by dumping it on younger Americans’ collective credit card.

GMU alum Thomas Savidge ponders “the moral crisis of Social Security.” A slice:

Political incentives explain the current impasse. Retirees have strong incentives to defend the benefits they have been promised and have incorporated into their retirement plans. Working Americans have incentive to resist higher taxes while preserving their own expected retirement income. Politicians, who want to get reelected, have incentives to avoid changes that immediately anger either group. All the while, future generations have no votes to offer and no representatives they can hold accountable.

My Mercatus Center colleague Jack Salmon decries the looming undoing, by the newly elected Democrats, of fiscal prudence at the state level. A slice:

It is these rainy day reserves that Texas Democrats are now seeking to draw down from, in order to fund gubernatorial campaign promises. Specifically, governor-elect Hinojosa pledged to send $1,500 checks to every Texan household in the state if she got elected. However, the Texas constitution prohibits sending government funded checks directly to individual households.

In order to get around these constitutional restrictions, legislative Democrats are formulating plans to declare an emergency. This could open up a legal route to raid the state’s rainy day funds, as the Texas constitution allows the distribution of direct funds for a “public calamity.” As the editorial board at the Washington Post notes:

“Just as President Donald Trump declared a bogus national emergency over the trade deficit, Texas Democrats want to declare a bogus public calamity over the cost of living, turning economic statistics into the legal equivalent of natural disasters to unlock sweeping government power.”

Joaquín Núñez writes about the late, great Milton Friedman, who died 20 years ago this month. (HT Scott Lincicome) A slice:

Peter Robinson, a researcher at the Hoover Institution and former speechwriter for Ronald Reagan, had his office in the same hallway as Milton Friedman. In fact, he interviewed him three times during the famous economist’s final decade. In one of those interviews, as Robinson recounted years later, Friedman made an argument that particularly caught his attention because of its reasoning.

“Milton I think you’re making a moral argument not an economic argument,” Robinson told him.

“A moral argument? Of course, is there any other kind?” Friedman replied.

Robinson never forgot that answer. To him, it summed up how Friedman understood his discipline. “For this great man, economics was not a game. It was a moral matter, human freedom as a moral matter, economic freedom was an aspect of human freedom. It was enabling people to better their lives. It wasn’t an intellectual construct and it wasn’t a game, it was something deep and important,” Robinson noted in 2018 in an interview with The Dartmouth Review.

{ 0 comments }

Quotation of the Day…

… is from page 77 of GMU Econ alums Scott Burns’s and Caleb Fuller’s forthcoming (in February 2027) book, Trade Wars: Why Freedom Trumps Tariffs:

Tariffs did, in fact, play a role in financing the early republic. But given the growth in the size of the federal government and its spending over the past two and a half centuries, they cannot come even close to funding today’s leviathan. The government that tariffs funded in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries was a minnow; today’s is Moby Dick.

{ 0 comments }

Some Links

Jack Nicastro busts the myth that Google forces schools to use AI.

Jim Bacchus urges Democrats to continue to oppose tariffs now that Trump’s power is waning. A slice:

Now that Democrats are set to take control of Congress, House Democratic Leader Hakeem Jeffries promises to repeal President Trump’s tariffs. “We will pass a bill to stop the stupid Trump tariffs jacking up prices on Americans,” he says. Democrats seem to have figured out that the Trump tariffs are bad.

When will they realize that almost all other tariffs are equally bad?

It’s unfortunate that Jensen Huang got caught in a Chinese honeypot, for he’s correct to warn of the dangers of export controls on microchips – as the Editorial Board of the Washington Post seems to agree. A slice:

Beijing has condemned the restrictions and threatened countermeasures. The stakes could be especially high for Taiwan. Its dominance of advanced chip manufacturing has long been regarded as a “silicon shield,” giving China an economic incentive to avoid a conflict that could destroy the island’s factories. But as Washington further restricts Chinese companies’ access to those same factories, Beijing might conclude that if it cannot benefit from Taiwan’s chipmaking prowess, nobody else should, either.

None of this is inevitable. But it is a reminder that the consequences of this stricter export-control regime could extend far beyond commerce.

Sam Gregg explains that “the increasingly wild promises of social democracy are what has led to economic stagnation — not the market.” A slice:

The long-term effects of these and related developments are not difficult to identify. Governments that increasingly resort to borrowing to cover the costs of social programs find that an expanding share of their annual budgets goes toward interest payments. As the size of public debts grows, interest rates go up. Servicing the public debt thus becomes progressively more expensive. Some governments will raise taxes to try to cover their social spending costs. But that also disincentivizes people to be entrepreneurial or work, thereby further weakening productivity.

If you talk to enough policymakers, few will deny the reality of this vicious fiscal circle or its unsustainability. Why then are so many of them unwilling to pursue the type of reforms necessary to address these problems?

Efforts to scale back social democratic policies invariably encounter three obstacles today. One is the existence of large constituencies who will resist any effort to reduce what they regard as “their” entitlements by voting or rioting against anyone proposing substantive reforms. The second is the willingness of many political parties of all stripes to pander to these parts of the electorate by promising not to touch entitlements. The third is the ongoing popularity of appeals to existing or newly imagined social rights to maintain or extend the state’s role in the economy.

Gale Pooley celebrates super glue.

George Will is right: “A presidency in the William Howard Taft tradition would be refreshing.” Two slices:

In 1913, during his last weeks as president, a bill to use literacy tests to ban “undesirable” immigrants came to William Howard Taft’s desk. A senator explained the bill: Immigrants included many “thugs, desperados … anarchists and criminals.” Sound familiar?

Taft, noting that many immigrants were “illiterate because opportunities have been denied them,” vetoed the bill. The Senate voted to override his veto, but the House sustained it.

Also, the Senate had recently approved constructing the Lincoln Memorial where Taft wanted it — where it is today, on the Potomac. The House, however, was recalcitrant: Maryland and Pennsylvania representatives favored a Lincoln Memorial highway to Gettysburg. But Taft’s ameliorative personality melted House opposition. Imagine that.

…..

“Genial” was contemporaries’ recurring description of Taft, who — such happy days are not here again — was known for his affability, infectious laughter and scarcity of enemies. Taft described his as a “humdrum” presidency. This now describes a national yearning.

Russ Roberts talks with Tyler Cowen about Montaigne.

Scott Lincicome tweets about a happy development – happy despite the fact that this development is undermining the comparative advantage of economists such as myself:

One of the best things AI has done for the policy world is enabling easy, almost-instant critiques of bad/misleading analysis that would otherwise go unreviewed. In a world of finite resources (especially time), it’s just incredibly useful.

{ 0 comments }

Quotation of the Day…

… is from page 298 of Thomas Sowell’s 1993 book, Inside American Education:

The first strategic objective in the battle for educational quality in the public schools must be destroying the monopoly of credentialing held by schools and academic departments of education.

{ 0 comments }

Here’s a letter to the Sun Chronicle.

Editor:

Desmond Lachman justly criticizes President Trump’s tariffs and the administration’s failure to reduce the gargantuan budget deficit (“Trump’s failed import tariff policy added to inflation,” November 13). But contrary to Mr. Lachman’s claim, it’s unclear that a restoration of fiscal prudence would reduce U.S. trade deficits. Perhaps the opposite would occur.

Obviously, every dollar that foreigners lend to the U.S. government is a dollar that foreigners don’t spend on U.S. exports and, thus, a dollar added to the U.S. trade deficit. But foreigners can and do invest in the U.S. in ways other than extending credit to our spendthrift government. It’s quite possible that, if Congress and the administration restored fiscal discipline to Washington, our economy’s investment climate would improve so much that global investors would increase their private-sector investments in America by enough to cause U.S. trade deficits to swell – an outcome that, despite Mr. Trump’s stubborn insistence otherwise, would be cause for America to celebrate.

Sincerely,
Donald J. Boudreaux
Professor of Economics
and
Martha and Nelson Getchell Chair for the Study of Free Market Capitalism at the Mercatus Center
George Mason University
Fairfax, VA 22030

{ 0 comments }

Some Links

These letters in today’s Wall Street Journal – one of which is written by GMU Econ alum Dave Hebert – expose the harmful unseriousness of the Trump administration’s trade team:

After reading U.S. Trade Representative Jamieson Greer’s letter, I’m scratching my head as to what the Trump administration believes the effect of tariffs are (“The Success of President Trump’s Trade Policy,” Nov. 16). The president says that tariffs are a tool in the effort to revitalize U.S. manufacturing. They do so by protecting U.S. firms from the competition of cheaper imports. Adding tariffs to the price of imports makes U.S. manufactured products more competitive within U.S. markets, and consumers can be expected to reallocate their expenditures accordingly.

But Mr. Greer says that only a fraction of the cost of tariffs is passed on to consumers. If so, why would consumers shift more purchases to American-made products, and how is U.S. manufacturing helped? Mr. Greer is making a claim irreconcilable with that of his boss. Which administration position am I supposed to believe?

Theodore A. Gebhard
Zionsville, Ind.
Mr. Gebhard was a senior economist with the International Trade Administration.

Mr. Greer deserves credit for his courage. In citing Caroline Freund’s paper which found that foreign exporters are absorbing “roughly 40-50% of the 2025 US tariff increases,” he recognizes that Americans have absorbed the remaining 50% to 60%. Mr. Greer’s other source, Preston Caldwell, agrees that “U.S. firms are still footing most of the tariff bill.”

Most other studies find that Americans, consumers and firms combined, are paying upwards of 90%. The Congressional Budget Office’s February report, written during a Republican Congress, finds that “foreign exporters will absorb 5% of the cost of tariffs,” leaving 95% to Americans. Pablo Fajgelbaum and Amit Khandelwal estimate that Americans absorb 90% of the tariffs. The Richmond Fed finds that Americans are paying near 100% of the tariffs.

The Trump administration promised that foreigners would pay all of the tariffs. Now, their top trade official concedes that Americans are paying, at a minimum, half of the tariffs. Voters took those higher prices and costs into account on Nov. 3.

David Hebert
American Inst. for Economic Research

Desmond Lachman surveys Trump’s harmful obsession with tariffing punitively taxing Americans’ purchases of imports. A slice:

The essential point is that a tariff is basically a tax paid by the importers. Importers might initially absorb some of that tax in terms of lower profit margins. However, in time they tend to pass most of the tax on to consumers. In addition, domestic producers who compete with imports can raise their own prices, and firms that rely on imported parts or materials face higher costs. This is especially true for industries that use aluminum and steel imports.

Ron Mau and Tucker Smith with the Dallas Fed estimated that tariff collections added nearly a full percentage point (0.8%) to the 12-month core PCE inflation rate.

Warren Coats is understandably critical of Oren Cass and the ‘New Right.’ Two slices:

Contrary to Reagan’s free-trade views that markets will allocate resources to the greatest benefit of all involved, the New Right “believes that a strong manufacturing sector on these shores provides the foundation for national power, technological innovation and stable communities — so the government should use tariffs and subsidies to support an industrial base that the market, as well as foreign powers, might otherwise undermine.” Trump’s use of tariffs generally had little to do with creating a level playing field that would maximize global income. Rather they reflected his bully approach for seeking other objectives. The fact is that US manufacturing output last year was virtually the same as it was at the end of 2001 when China entered the World Trade Organization. However, employment in manufacturing has fallen because of increased labor productivity, surely a good thing. And as our economy is fully employed, the reduced manufacturing workers have found jobs elsewhere.

…..

But Cass’s most obnoxious misrepresentation of Reagan Republicans’ views has to do with the role of virtue and its sources. Cass claims that: “The Reaganites believe strongly that liberty is the most important end unto itself. People with the liberty to make their own choices can maximize their own well-being, in this thinking, and a nation focused on protecting that liberty will enjoy the greatest freedom and prosperity as a result… The New Right finds this absurd. Liberty cannot mean only license to do what one wants… Between the extremes of moral relativism and oppressive conformity lies an enormous expanse in which the state can and should establish priorities, including strong families and stable communities.”

There is no way Cass is not aware of the importance Reagan Republicans put on virtue and of its development in the private sector. This is what the discussion of “fusionism” was all about. “Not all Freedom Conservatives see our project in explicitly fusionist terms, as a formal philosophical synthesis of freedom and order, liberty and virtue. But all FreeCons do believe that unless we take virtue seriously, demand it of our leaders, and transmit it to future generations, the American experiment in self-government will not be sustainable.”

Kenneth Costello runs us through some economics of data-center development.

Wall Street Journal columnist Jason Riley asks: “If ‘systemic racism’ is real, how did Scott Colom win?” A slice:

A recent Journal editorial on the election of Scott Colom, who will become Mississippi’s first black U.S. senator since Reconstruction and its first Democratic senator in 38 years, ended by asking: “Why won’t Democrats celebrate America’s manifest racial progress?”

It’s a question many reasonable people have been asking at least since Barack Obama won the presidency nearly 20 years ago. Mr. Obama not only claimed the popular vote twice in what remains a majority-white country, he won some of the palest states—Iowa, Wisconsin, Vermont, Maine, Ohio, New Hampshire. Even in Southern states he lost, such as Georgia, Texas and South Carolina, Mr. Obama garnered more white support than John Kerry in 2004 and Al Gore in 2000.

What makes Mr. Colom’s victory especially noteworthy is that Mississippi played an important role in the history of black civil rights, albeit for all the wrong reasons. Martin Luther King Jr. called it “the most difficult state in the United States in race relations.” It is where Medgar Evers, an NAACP official and Army veteran, was gunned down in 1963 for trying to organize black voters. It was the home of Fannie Lou Hamer, who challenged the seating of Mississippi’s all-white delegation at the 1964 Democratic National Convention. It’s where 14-year-old Emmett Till was abducted and killed by a group of white men in 1955, an event that gained wide media attention in the North and energized the civil-rights movement.

Liberals discuss voter suppression as if we were still living in the Eisenhower era, but in 2012 blacks turned out to vote at higher rates than whites. Democrats likewise maintain that blacks must be segregated in racially gerrymandered districts to ensure the election of black lawmakers. Yet as far back as 1982, five black candidates from mostly white districts won seats in the North Carolina Legislature. In more recent decades, both parties have elected black congressional candidates from majority-white districts, including Democrats Alan Wheat of Missouri and Sanford Bishop of Georgia and Republicans Gary Franks of Connecticut, Allen West of Florida and Mia Love of Utah. The Brookings Institution reports that in the current Congress, “only eight out of the 61 Black House members were elected from majority-Black districts.”

Most people cheer these political developments in a nation with our ugly history of black oppression, yet many liberals do so only reluctantly, while others pretend that the country is as antiblack ever. Voter ID laws are “Jim Crow in the 21st century,” according to Joe Biden. Systemic racism is “the air we breathe,” Pete Buttigieg claims. Self-styled antiracist activist Ibram X. Kendi insists that “to grow up in America is to grow up, and for racist ideas to constantly be rained on your head and you have no umbrella. And you don’t even know that you’re wet with those racist ideas, because the racist ideas themselves cause you to imagine that you’re dry.”

Despite growing evidence to the contrary, you’re expected to believe that white racism continues to be the country’s defining feature. Liberals traffic in racial resentment to advance an agenda that has far more to do with maintaining their own influence and relevance than with addressing social inequality. Democrats spend a lot of time arguing that black people can’t get ahead due to racism, which make blacks who do succeed a threat. Hence the eagerness to play down or ignore obvious progress. If support for black candidates has increased this year, you’re told, it isn’t because racial tensions have subsided. Rather, it’s because the GOP’s voter suppression efforts didn’t work as planned. Heads they win, tails you lose.

Jacob Sullum reports that “Trump says he welcomes foreign students. His policies tell a different story.”

GMU Econ alum Dominic Pino tweets:

You’ll never believe it, but Spain did rent controls and now there’s a housing shortage.

{ 0 comments }

Quotation of the Day…

… is from page 154 of the 2019 Mercatus Center edition of my emeritus GMU Econ colleague Richard Wagner’s excellent 1998 book, To Promote the General Welfare:

Any creation of an entitlement or sheltered status concomitantly entails either a limitation on the ability of someone else to earn a livelihood or a taking of some of the results of previous effort.

DBx: Indeed so.

For example, protectionists are forever patting themselves on their backs for what they take to be their magnanimous assistance to protected workers and firm-owners. Yet they never scold themselves for their thoughtless disregard not only of consumers who must pay higher prices, but also of the workers and firms who, as a result of this faux magnanimity, necessarily lose particular jobs and economic opportunities.

{ 0 comments }